Home : Magazine : The Reserve Vol. 38, No. 18 : Player Magazine 38 18 Stephen Chidwick Dark Side Perfectionism Commentary

The Dark Side Of Perfectionism


Stephen Chidwick

Hello.

Many of you will know me as that poker player in the high rollers who doesn’t say very much. For a long time, I guess I didn’t really think I had much of value to say.

I’ve kept a low profile for most of my life. I’ve built my career with a quiet determination and focus on the things I could control — my preparation, my decisions, my consistency.

“I don’t waste my time with social media,” I told myself, and others. And while that decision was undoubtedly the right one for me at the time, the reasons were fabricated, or at least incomplete. What I didn’t admit so explicitly was my fear: a fear of criticism, of vulnerability, and of my inability to control my own obsessive nature.

I would almost certainly meet the criteria for autism spectrum disorder. I would almost certainly meet the criteria for bipolar disorder, though I never stuck around long enough after an episode to receive a formal diagnosis (whether or not I identify with these labels is a topic for another day). I’ve known the isolation of being forcibly separated from society, for my own protection, and wondering how I got there. I’ve experienced being so socially drained from a day of live poker that I’ve gone to sleep hungry. Not because I was so focused that I lost my appetite, but because those one or two brief human interactions required to feed myself were just too much.

I know how absurd that sounds — I knew it back then, too — but no amount of rationality stopped it from being true.

Over time, I slowly adapted. I learned how to sublimate that anxious energy and turn it into a motivating force, into an obsession and focused drive to reach my potential as a poker player, to prove my worth to the world through external accomplishments.

And then, the validation I was seeking started coming.

In 2019, I was voted by my peers in a Card Player survey of fellow high roller players as the best player in the world. (Editor’s Note: Chidwick received a whopping 24 of the 76 total votes placed for best player. There were also four ‘haters’ who said he was the most overrated.)

My dreams had become reality, and my ego had a field day, but it wasn’t long before I realized there was still a piece missing.

Despite everything I had accomplished, I was no less fragile. Now that I was painted as “the best,” there was no margin for error. Every misstep felt like a threat to the whole narrative.

Am I slipping? Am I getting old and complacent, or lazy? How much longer can I keep tricking people into thinking I’m so good when I know how big my mistakes can be?

And none of that even touched the root of what I was actually seeking underneath it all — to be accepted. So, when someone threw out any offhanded criticism, whether it was calling me “boring,” “robotic,” or saying I “had no personality,” I took it to heart. Because somewhere in me, I was scared they were right.

Driven by my desire to be the best poker player I could be, I started doing deeper inner work, peeling back the layers of my belief structure and examining what was uncovered. Why did I feel like I had to be perfect to be worthy? What was I really seeking through my success? These were uncomfortable investigations that slowly but surely started to free me from my preconceived notions of who I was and who I should be.

And I saw the benefits — in my performance at the table, yes — but more so in my day-to-day interactions with my family, my friends, casual acquaintances, and even total strangers. The progress empowered me and urged me onwards. The more I leaned into vulnerability, honesty, and trust in others, the more confident, authentic, and self-assured I felt.

I’m learning to listen not only to my precious logic but also to the quiet, mysterious, unexplainable voice within. The voice that speaks when I am silent. The voice that compelled me to write this, and then expose it for the entire poker world to see.

And so here I am — the kid inside the robot costume. Just another human being in pursuit of love, connection, and belonging, tired of running from his shadow and ready to stop and turn around. At least I hope so.

This message is for anyone who feels trapped in the darkness. I’ve lived through times that felt unbearable — where the idea of peace, or connection, or even a quiet mind felt impossibly far away. If you’re in that place right now, I want you to know that it can get better. You’re not broken. You’re not beyond help. Keep going.

I also want to thank all the people who saw something in me that I took a long time to see in myself and guided me down this path. Some will know who they are. Others may never realize how much a small gesture meant to someone who was struggling. I’m deeply grateful for all of you.

Stephen Chidwick is one of the most accomplished tournament players in poker history. The Octopi Poker ambassador currently sits third on the all-time money list with more than $68 million in cashes. The former online poker standout has two World Series of Poker bracelets, is also fourth on the PLO all-time money list. The 36-year-old from Deal, England has won the Card Player Player of the Year award twice, in 2019 and 2022. You can follow him on Twitter/X @ChidwickStephen.