Poker In Court: U.S. v. DiCristina Reversed
PPA Calls Ruling 'Unfortunate' But Doesn't Change Poker As Game Of Skill
On Tuesday, a federal court overturned the ruling from U.S. v. Lawrence DiCristina in August 2012, which included testimony that poker is a game of skill, rather than chance.
The lower court had reached a judgment of acquittal in favor of Lawrence DiCristina, setting aside the guilty verdict on a couple of counts related to the Illegal Gambling Business Act, a federal statute. DiCristina was arrested in 2011 and charged and convicted of running an illegal gambling business.
He currently faces up to a decade in prison for spreading a poker game in a Staten Island, New York warehouse while taking a five-percent rake.
DiCristina and a co-defendant pleaded guilty on December 12, 2011, but on May 1, 2012 DiCristina was permitted to withdraw his guilty plea, and the case proceeded to trial.
The lower court run by Judge Jack Weinstein decided to set aside the guilty verdict because it said poker isn’t covered by the IGBA. The federal government appealed the decision.
“Because we find that the plain language of the IGBA covers DiCristina’s poker business, we reverse the judgment of acquittal and remand to the District Court with instructions to reinstate the jury verdict, enter a judgment of conviction on both counts, and proceed with sentencing DiCristina,” the ruling from the higher court stated.
The Poker Players Alliance called the decision “unfortunate” but that the “2nd Circuit clearly did not dispute the district court’s finding that poker is a game of skill,” adding that “this is a key point distinguishing poker from the types of gambling games that Congress and state legislatures have often tried to prohibit. What the court did was conclude that the IGBA doesn’t set forth an independent federal definition of gambling, but instead only incorporates state law.”
In other words, Tuesday’s ruling is bad news for DiCristina, but not so bad for the poker community at large, according to the Poker Players Alliance.
“The PPA stands ready to support Mr. DiCristina should he choose to appeal this decision, and we are committed to working through the judicial and legislative processes to establish a clear definition of gambling based on the predominance test,” the PPA concluded.
|1||Dan Bilzerian Talks Nosebleed Poker With Howard Stern|
|2||Report: Phil Ivey Posts $1 Million Bail For Fellow High-Stakes Poker Player Paul Phua, Son Darren Phua|
|3||Atlantic City Casino Caesars Robbed Of $181,000|
|4||Poker Strategy -- Daniel Negreanu On Balance Versus Adaptability|
|5||2014 World Series of Poker ESPN TV Schedule|
|6||Atlantic City Struggling To Maintain Status As Top Poker Destination|
|7||Poker Strategy With Dusty Schmidt: Preflop Open Limping|
|8||During L.A. Traffic Jam, Drivers Get Out Of Their Cars And Play Poker|
|9||Wynn Plans To Use 250K Live Oysters To Help Clean Up Contaminated River Alongside Proposed Casino Site|
|10||Online Poker: Viktor Blom Cuts 2014 Deficit In Half|
|1||One Drop Winner Daniel Colman Didn't Talk To Media Because He Sees Poker 'As A Very Dark Game'|
|2||Pamela Anderson Divorces Rick Salomon Just Days After He Won $2.8 Million In 'Big One For One Drop'|
|3||Daniel Negreanu Had 87 Percent Of Himself In $1 Million One Drop Poker Tournament, Agent Says|
|4||Dozens Gamble On $1,000 Flips For World Series Of Poker Main Event Seat|
|5||Daniel Colman Wins $15.3 Million In 2014 World Series of Poker Big One For One Drop|
|6||It Appears Poker Legend Doyle Brunson Has Played His Last WSOP Main Event|
|7||High-Stakes Poker Player Paul Phua Arrested In Las Vegas For Allegedly Taking Bets On World Cup|
|8||Poker Pro Chad Brown Loses His Battle With Cancer|
|9||November Nine Set For World Series of Poker Main Event Final Table|
|10||With Top-Two Finish In One Drop, Daniel Negreanu Takes Lead On All-Time Tournament Money List|