Poker Coverage: Poker Legislation Poker Business Poker Tournaments Daily Fantasy Sports

South Carolina Supreme Court Says Home Poker Games Illegal

Any Play For Real Money Violates Law From Year 1802

Print-icon
 

South Carolina has flip-flopped on poker once again.

The state’s Supreme Court ruled last week that the illegal gambling convictions of five men should not have been overturned in 2009. The case stems from a raid of a private real-money poker game three years prior. The game, located in Charleston, had been advertised online.

“The reason we’re fighting the law is because we want to get our state representatives to change this law,” Bob Chimento, one of the defendants in the case, said years ago. “We’re just a bunch of average Joes playing cards. We want to be able to play cards in our homes. They’re trying to intimidate people to quit playing poker.”

The legal battle went on for more than six years prior to last week’s ruling.

The Associated Press reported that the Supreme Court sees these poker games as unlawful, even if run from home, and it doesn’t matter under the law whether poker is a game of skill.

“Whether an activity is gaming/gambling is not dependent upon the relative roles of chance and skill, but whether there is money or something of value wagered on the game’s outcome,” the justices wrote in the split decision.

The opinion is in direct conflict with a circuit judge who wrote in 2009 that since poker isn’t like traditional gambling it wouldn’t fall under the anti-gambling statute.

The law that applies to the case dates back more than two hundred years. It bans “any game with cards or dice” — stretching as far as to potentially cover board games.

Home games where no money is exchanged appear to be OK, according to the recent opinion.

The muddled legal waters have prompted some in the state to push for changing the law. According to the Associated Press, lawmakers tried this year to make “friendly” home games explicitly legal, but efforts didn’t progress.

One justice wrote that the current law is “hopelessly outdated.”

South Carolina currently allows lotteries and charitable gambling. The state doesn’t allow land-based casinos, although some are trying to bring those to South Carolina.

The state has two casino boats that offer Las Vegas-style gambling. These boats sail three miles into international waters before gamblers are allowed to place bets.

 
 
 
 

Comments

x19
2 years ago

wow, its scary and astounding that in this day and age that there are people sitting on a supreme court that really think like this.....and to think that these clowns will sit in judgement of others is sickening on a visceral level....these idiots who call themselves "justices" should be washing dishes rather than making legal rulings.

 
Reply
 

Tahosa65
2 years ago

Not all the retarded are in extended care centers. Some even advance to state supreme courts. Those with learning disabilities, I'm not talking about you but about the intellectually retarded who chose to be so. When this law was written the state still allowed slavery. We need a president to issue another emancipation proclamation, this time for poker players.

 
Reply
 

swallsjr
almost 2 years ago

The judges' game. I'd heard about it for years on the street, before I was even in law school. A rotating group of ten or twelve judges, prosecutors, and professors. They all have money, and in my playing days it would have been pretty sweet to have any one of them owing me favors. Only problem is, no one can get in the game anymore. One rounder, Crispy Linetta, sat under some pretense, but when they found out he was a pro, he couldn't cross the street without a legal hassle. Even his regular club, Vorshay's, got shut down. Place'd been open since 1907

 
Reply